USMLE Step 1 has been reported as pass/fail for exams taken on or after January 26, 2022. You won’t receive a three-digit score, but you’ll still need to prepare carefully, and it’s understandable to have questions about what this means for your residency plans.
I’ll walk you through how scoring works, what we’ve learned since the change, and how to approach your preparation. We’ll also look at what pass/fail means for residency applications, so you have a clearer sense of where to focus your time and energy.
Step 1 Pass Rates Before and After the Scoring Change
Step 1 pass rates fell following the transition to pass/fail, but increased across the reported groups in 2025. The latest figures offer a more encouraging picture than the earlier downward trend alone suggests.
Here’s how pass rates have changed since 2021, the last full year of numerical scoring:
| Year | Examinees from MD-granting schools* | Examinees from DO-granting schools | Examinees from Schools outside the U.S./Canada* |
| 2021 | 95% | 94% | 77% |
| 2022 | 91% | 91% | 71% |
| 2023 | 90% | 86% | 68% |
| 2024 | 89% | 86% | 70% |
| 2025 | 91% | 89% | 72% |
Source: USMLE performance data. Figures include first-time and repeat administrations. Through 2024, Canadian schools were grouped with U.S. schools; beginning in 2025, they are grouped with non-U.S. schools. The final column therefore includes Canadian schools in 2025.
One possible explanation for the initial drop is that students changed how they studied. Without a numerical score to aim for, some may have spent less time preparing for Step 1 and put more energy into clinical rotations or other parts of their residency applications. That shift makes sense, but studying “just enough to pass” can be harder to judge than it sounds.
There were other changes happening, too. The passing standard increased when pass/fail reporting began in January 2022, so we can’t pin the decline entirely on study habits.
The good news is that pass rates improved in all three reported groups in 2025. They were still below 2021 levels, but the downward trend didn’t continue. Keep in mind that Canadian examinees changed reporting groups in 2025, so the comparisons aren’t exact.
My advice is to avoid treating “pass/fail” as “low stakes.” You don’t need to chase the highest possible numerical score, but you do need a preparation plan that gives you a comfortable margin for passing. Let your practice exams and your school’s guidance (not the absence of a reported score) determine when you’re ready to test.
Read Next: USMLE Test Day — Set Yourself Up for Success
Pass/Fail Hasn't Removed the Stress of Step 1
Removing the pressure to earn a high numerical score may offer some relief, but preparing for Step 1 can still feel stressful. You’re covering a lot of material, deciding when you’re ready, and thinking about what the result means for your next steps.
A 2024 study of 102 students at Drexel found that, despite a 97% pass rate, 75% reported poor sleep quality and 68% reported mild to moderate anxiety. About two-thirds felt their commitment to medical education exceeded what was reasonable for their well-being.
So what could help? A 2025 study of student perspectives at the University of South Dakota identified several areas where schools could strengthen support:
- More frequent academic advisor meetings
- Better access to mental health counselors
- More opportunities to stay connected with peers
- Greater access to NBME-style practice materials
- Structured peer mentoring for Step 1 preparation
My advice is to use those resources early. If you’re struggling with your study plan, feeling isolated, or regularly losing sleep, you don’t have to wait until you’re overwhelmed to ask for help.
There’s also room to recognize the benefits of the change. Emily Zitkovsky, a medical graduate from Brown University, offers this perspective:
Overall, I think this is a net positive change. Medical school and applying to residency are stressful, regardless. Removing the emphasis on perfection and the need to memorize small details that aren’t super clinically relevant is a good thing for most people. My best advice to medical students is to focus on learning at whatever stage you are at. You can’t control changes to the NBME exams or the residency application process, but developing a strong foundation in preclinical and clinical medicine will benefit your patients and your future success.
You can’t control every change in board exams or residency selection. You can focus on building your knowledge, checking your readiness, and getting support along the way.
Watch This Free Webinar: Preparing for the USMLE Step 1
Some of the Pressure Has Shifted to Step 2 CK
One goal of the scoring change was to reduce the emphasis on numerical Step 1 scores. But removing that score doesn’t remove the pressure to stand out when applying for residency. For some students, it shifts more of that pressure toward Step 2 CK.
A 2024 survey of 127 Penn State medical students illustrates that tension: most respondents supported making Step 1 pass/fail, yet students reported increased anxiety about Step 2 scores. It’s possible to welcome the change and still worry about what comes next.
That concern makes sense. Step 2 CK provides a numerical score that programs can consider, and preparing for it often overlaps with demanding clinical rotations and residency application planning. Without a numerical Step 1 result, students may feel they have fewer opportunities to demonstrate their strengths through board scores.
Still, Step 2 CK is one part of your application, not your entire application. I recommend planning for it early while continuing to build your clinical skills, relationships with mentors, and understanding of your specialty interests.
Maya Guhan, an MD/MBA graduate from Baylor College of Medicine who took Step 1 after the scoring change, described her experience this way:
I feel that the stress has shifted to a different period of time. Students now feel that they have to do something to “stand out.” Some competitive residency applicants have even felt increased pressure to take a research year.
To be honest, I am not sure how Step 1 being P/F will affect residency match rates and overall student education in the long run, and I’m not sure if faculty or program directors know either. At this point, I feel that my peers and I are worried about our future and doing whatever we can to differentiate ourselves, without knowing exactly what it is that program directors are looking for.
Building a Residency Application Beyond Board Scores
With Step 1 reported as pass/fail, the rest of your application gives programs more context about your strengths and interests. Your clinical performance, letters of recommendation, research, service, and leadership help show what you could bring to a residency program.
That doesn’t mean you need to fill every spare hour with another activity. I recommend choosing experiences that let you contribute, take on responsibility, and explore your interests. Specialty-related opportunities can be useful, but an experience doesn’t have to match your future specialty to be meaningful.
The MyERAS application allows up to 10 selected experiences, with up to three identified as most meaningful. These aren’t limited to extracurriculars, and the limit applies to what you report, not how many activities you can participate in during medical school.
Think about what you’ll be able to explain afterward: What did you contribute? What did you learn? How did the experience shape the way you work with others or approach patient care?
Looking beyond a numerical Step 1 score gives programs more room to understand those qualities. For you, the practical takeaway is to build a few meaningful commitments rather than chase a longer list, while leaving enough time for your coursework, clinical training, and exam preparation.
What Pass/Fail Means for Equity in Residency Selection
Removing a numerical Step 1 score doesn’t automatically remove the barriers students face when applying to residency. It may reduce emphasis on one measure while leaving differences in access to mentorship, research, and clinical opportunities unresolved.
A 2024 survey of 433 program directors in competitive specialties found that 76% expected the scoring change to leave matching difficulty unchanged or reduce it for applicants underrepresented in medicine. However, respondents also ranked Step 2 CK scores and away rotations at their programs as their two most important selection factors.
That raises a practical concern: if more weight falls on experiences that require funding, connections, or institutional support, students with fewer resources may still face significant barriers. The survey captures program directors’ expectations rather than proving how the change affected Match outcomes, but it highlights why scoring reform alone may not be enough.
Physician Advisor Amar Mandalia, MD points to differences in the opportunities available across medical schools:
Survey results on the perception of scoring change to P/F for Step 1 published in October 2021 demonstrated students/residents who identified as Underrepresented in Medicine (UiM) welcomed the change. They felt that it would decrease inequities between UiM and non-UiM.
Now, with a few years of data, we see the international students have seen the largest drop in pass rates — only marginally worse than DO students and first-time testers. IMGs are typically UIM, so the P/F system does not seem to help underrepresented communities in this way.
I also see that the increased emphasis on Step 2 further highlights inequities seen in medical education and extracurricular opportunities between lower- and higher-tier programs.
Higher-tier medical schools may encourage students to pursue research and extracurricular activities that they have to offer for a holistic approach. Lower-tier programs, where resources could be sparse or lacking, may not be able to afford the same opportunities to their students.
The concern here is access: students don’t all have the same opportunities to build their applications, regardless of their ability or commitment.
It’s also important to distinguish underrepresented-in-medicine status from IMG status. The former concerns racial and ethnic representation in medicine; the latter describes where someone received their medical education. These groups can overlap, but they aren’t interchangeable.
My advice is to seek guidance early about opportunities and support available through your school, specialty organizations, and potential mentors. Ask about funding and eligibility before committing to an away rotation or research experience, and work with your advisor to prioritize opportunities that fit your goals and circumstances.
What Pass/Fail Means for DO and IMG Applicants
For some DO students and international medical graduates (IMGs), a strong numerical Step 1 score offered another way to demonstrate their academic strengths. Without that score, it’s understandable to wonder how programs will compare applicants from different medical school backgrounds.
Those concerns also appeared in the 2024 survey of competitive-specialty program directors. About 49% expected matching to become more difficult for DO applicants after the scoring change, while 56% expected greater difficulty for IMGs. These were only predictions, but they help explain why applicants have questions.
Overall Match rates don’t settle the issue. A higher placement rate or a larger number of matched applicants doesn’t show how the scoring change affected someone’s chances at a particular program or specialty.
There is encouraging news on exam performance: USMLE’s 2025 data show first-time Step 1 pass rates increased to 89% for DO examinees and 75% for examinees from non-U.S. schools. The latter category includes Canadian schools beginning in 2025, so comparisons with earlier years need that context.
My advice is to focus on the evidence of readiness you can provide: a Step 1 pass, thoughtful preparation for Step 2 CK, strong clinical work, and letters from people who know your abilities. Review individual programs’ eligibility and exam policies early, and work with an advisor familiar with your background and specialty goals.
Read Next: Step 1 pass/fail considerations for IMG applicants
How to Prepare for Step 1 With Confidence
You don’t need a perfect study plan, but you do need a realistic one, and a way to check that it’s working. If you’re worried about Step 1, I recommend starting with these steps:
- Build a manageable study schedule. Plan around your coursework and other commitments, with time for content review, practice questions, and rest. Revisit your schedule as you learn which areas need more attention.
- Use practice questions to understand your mistakes. When reviewing a missed question, ask whether you lacked the knowledge, misread the scenario, or struggled to apply what you knew. That gives you something specific to work on.
- Check your readiness with practice assessments. Look at your performance across recent assessments rather than relying on one reassuring result. Review your progress with your school’s academic support team, especially if your results are inconsistent or close to the passing threshold.
- Prioritize gaps in frequently tested material. Use the exam content outline and your practice results to guide your review. Build connections between foundational sciences and patient scenarios rather than trying to memorize every detail.
- Practice making decisions under time pressure. If you’re unsure, eliminate answers where you can, choose your best remaining option, and move on. Flag the question if you want to revisit it before ending the block.
- Ask for support early. If you’re falling behind, feeling overwhelmed, or unsure whether to keep your test date, talk with your advisor or academic support team. You don’t have to figure it all out alone.
Read Next: Studying for USMLE Step 1
FAQs
All USMLE test scores are delivered within 2-8 weeks after your test date. The NBME says that while most results are delivered within 4 weeks, you should allow up to 8 weeks in case of unforeseen circumstances.
Your score will remain available and free to access for approximately one year after your test date.
According to the NBME, no individual or group may have USMLE test results accelerated for any reason. You’ll need to wait in line for your scores, regardless of extenuating circumstances.
You can take Step 1 up to 3 times within 12 months. Your 4th attempt must be at least 1 year after your first attempt and 6 months after your most recent attempt.
You cannot retake a Step if you have passed — unless your scores are out of date for your residency application.
If you have to take the USMLE more than once, your chances of matching into a competitive specialty drop dramatically. Every Fail is reported on your residency application.
- Showing a strong performance on USMLE Step 2 CK
- Earning strong clerkship grades and a strong Medical Student Performance Evaluation from your medical school
- Obtaining excellent letters of recommendation
- Strengthening other aspects of your application, like research experience, volunteer work, or other relevant extracurricular activities
- Applying to programs that may be more forgiving of a Step 1 failure or that take a more holistic approach to their review of applicants
- Networking effectively within the medical community to establish professional relationships that can aid in securing interviews
- Taking a research year if you think your application would benefit from more research
MedSchoolCoach Offers Personalized USMLE Step 1 Tutoring
USMLE Step 1 is vital to getting your license to practice medicine. The Pass/Fail scoring system seems to have increased student stress while decreasing student pass rate. However, the USMLE committee has recently chosen not to revert any changes to the scoring system.
If you’re concerned about your USMLE exam scores, let our experienced tutors help you craft a personalized study plan that makes sense for your schedule and unique needs. The more prepared you are, the less stressed you’ll feel!
Jeanie Gribben, MD
Dr. Gribben is a graduate of the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai and a Merrill Presidential Scholar from Cornell University. She offers tutoring for Steps 1 and 2 and med school coursework, as well as advising support for medical students. She’s dedicated to personalized teaching strategies for student success.
